The Differences Between Buying a Second Home vs. Investment Property

The Differences Between Buying a Second Home vs. Investment Property

The journey of owning a home doesn't always stop at the first property. Many people find themselves deciding between a second home and an investment property. While both options can be great paths to build wealth and have unique benefits, they also differ significantly in their purposes, the financial implications, and the lifestyle they support. Rental property owners earn roughly 45% more than the median household income, hinting at the lucrative nature of investment properties.

Fast Facts about Investment Properties

Here are some noteworthy statistics about investment properties sourced from various organizations:
  • As per BankRate, the U.S. has approximately 48.2 million rental units housed within almost 20 million properties.

  • Most rental properties (70%) are under individual investors' ownership. Comparatively, for-profit corporations own a smaller 18% share of properties but hold 45% of all rental units.

  • Around 34% of U.S. households are comprised of tenants, with 42% occupying single-family homes and 36% living in apartments with five or more units. It's worth noting that 47% of all renters are under 30 years old.

Quick Insights about Second Homes

Let's look at some notable data about second homes:
  • As of 2018, there were around 1.5 million second homes in the US, according to Gitnux, reflecting the varied motivations behind such investments.

  • In 2020, sales of second homes in the US surged by 30%, demonstrating the appeal of the freedom and flexibility that come with owning a second home.

  • Interestingly, 24% of U.S. second-home buyers in 2020 intended to generate rental income through short-term letting.

Differences in Mortgages for Second Homes and Investment Properties

Interest Rates for Mortgages

Interest rates for mortgages on second homes and investment properties are often set higher than those for primary residences. This difference reflects the greater risk associated with these loans, as lenders perceive that borrowers may be more likely to default on a mortgage for a non-primary residence. The rate can vary depending on a variety of factors, including the borrower's credit score, the loan-to-value ratio, the type of property, and the overall economic climate. It's advisable for buyers to shop around with various lenders to find the best interest rate and to understand how these factors may influence the rate they are offered.

Down Payments: An Important Consideration

When purchasing a second home or an investment property, potential buyers should be prepared for the possibility of higher down payment requirements. Typically, lenders require more significant down payments for investment properties than for second homes, sometimes even up to 30% of the purchase price. This increased down payment reflects the perceived higher risk associated with investment properties, as they may not be as stable as a primary residence. A higher down payment also generally means a lower mortgage interest rate, potentially saving money in the long run.

Requirements for Mortgage Approval

The process for obtaining a mortgage for an investment property can be more complex and stringent compared to that for a second home or primary residence. Lenders usually examine factors such as the projected rental income, the buyer's debt-to-income ratio, credit history, employment status, and the overall financial health of the applicant. These requirements are designed to ensure that the buyer can manage the additional financial responsibility that comes with owning an investment property. It's essential for applicants to prepare well in advance, gathering the necessary documentation and seeking professional advice if needed, to ensure a smoother approval process.

Factoring in Rental Income

For those seeking to invest in a property with the intention of earning rental income, lenders often consider this potential income stream when determining mortgage qualification. This rental income can make it easier to qualify for an investment property mortgage, as it adds to the borrower's overall income. However, lenders may have specific criteria for how they calculate this income, and it's often discounted to some degree to account for potential vacancies and other risks.

Conversely, rental income is typically not considered when applying for a mortgage on a second home, as the property is intended for personal use rather than as an income-generating asset. Understanding these nuances can help prospective buyers to plan effectively and navigate the mortgage application process for investment properties and second homes.

Misrepresentation of Investment Property as a Second Home: A Cautionary Note

Converting a Second Home to an Investment Property Post Purchase

It's essential to be upfront about the intended use of the property. Misrepresenting an investment property as a second home can be considered mortgage fraud. However, after closing on a second home, homeowners can decide to turn it into an investment property.

About Connie Widmann Team

The tight-knit group of professional REALTORS that make up Connie Widmann & Team brings together a diverse set of skills, addressing every facet of the real estate experience. The team is unified by the common goal of transforming clients' real estate dealings into enjoyable and successful ventures.

Leading the team is Connie Widmann, who has established herself as a top-selling REALTOR in Newtown, where she has resided for over 20 years. Her team's accomplishments are nothing short of impressive, as reflected in her roles and awards, including Sales Vice President, a top 3% ranking in the Platinum Club companywide for 2020 and 2021, and recognition as the Top Producing and Listing Team in the office from 2018 to 2021. They also secured the title of Top Selling Team in the office in 2021 and were among the Top 25 Team in closed units and sales volume companywide in 2020, continuing their streak as a Top 25 Team company-wide in 2021 and 2022.

If you're looking to buy or sell a home or have any questions about the Connecticut real estate market, contact Connie Widmann & Team today.

Work With Us

Connie Widmann & Team is happy to provide you with a free market evaluation to help determine what your home is worth in today's marketplace, meet with you to guide you in preparing your home for the marketplace, or get you headed in the right direction when renting or purchasing your new home. If there is anything we can help you with, call or email us and we will be in touch!

Follow Us on Instagram